Tom Petty wins songwriting royalties, but does it make sense?

Currently trending is an article about Tom Petty winning songwriting royalties against a contemporary artist named "Sam Smith." The song called "Stay with me" which I obviously hadn't heard until now. With a constant loop of rock music and facts circulating through my head at all times; I am definitely bias when it comes to being able to hear rock influence in new songs. So I just had to hear this song to see if I heard it too, which I assumed I would.

Sam Smith "Stay with me"

Tom Petty "I wont back down"

Only after listening to certain parts of Sam Smith's song several times do I hear any similarities. The beat is similar, but slowed down throughout the song. It feels like a stretch to call this a straight reference to Tom Petty's tune. I think this is getting carried away. And I'll tell ya why.

The song’s credit on ASCAP — that’s the American Society of Composers, Authors, and Publishers —now lists Smith, Petty, Lynne, and Jimmy Napes as the chief songwriters.

So because the song sounds similar, you now get to put your name in the song writing credits? Let's get real for a sec, if we're going to do that for every song that sounds like another we're back dated on a LOT of music. I can literally list all the songs that are much more clearly ripping off/referencing a popular song that people seemed to have little or no problem with:

Green Day "Warning" The Kinks "Picture Book"
KD Lang "Constant Craving" Rolling Stones "Anybody seen my baby"
One Direction "Best song ever" The Who "Baby O'Reilly"
Lady Gaga "Alejandro" Ace of Base "Don't turn around"
Robin Thicke "Blurred lines" Marvin Gaye "Got to give it up"
Most rap songs that sample old rock music
Ice ice baby, anyone?
We could be here all day.

Songs sounding like other songs is nothing new, classic rock songs are no exception. I'm starting to wonder if this is more of a case of Tom Petty having some pretty damn good lawyers who saw an opportunity. This is knit picking. This is completely coincidental and pretty damn subjective. What do you think?

Comments

The album art of Tommy by Mike McInnerney

People often ask me what my favorite album is. Without much thought I am able to answer them. The Who's 1969 album "Tommy" is my favorite record of all time. The album artwork also happens to be my favorite. Recently I was thinking about the album and how it affected me in my life. I decided to look up the Tommy album art and was surprised that I was unable to find any of it. I could find the cover, but never all the album art inside. The Tommy CD comes with a booklet with lyrics and a series of different illustrations. But they weren't on the internet. So this blog will be changing that! I just took out my CD booklet and scanned all the artwork. There are two versions of the cover, one featuring small images of their faces inserted into the gaps in the central sphere. The other is just the original work. Executives at The Who's record label insisted on having the band members pictured on the cover, so that's why there are two covers. Pete Tow...

[REVISED] Eddie Vedder's voice, the most emulated voice in music history?

Pearl Jam's Eddie Vedder has one of the most distinct and emulated voices in contemporary rock music. I feel like I spent the entire 90's hearing alternative bands copying Eddie's singing style. Just to show you how many artists have been said to sound like Eddie Vedder throughout time; Creed's Scott Stapp, Fuel's Brett Scallions, The Stone Temple Pilot's Scott Weiland, The Calling's Alex Band, Soundgarden's Chris Cornell, Lifehouse's Jason Wade, and some say Nickelback's Chad Kroeger have a similar sounding voice (don't shoot the messenger). And probably more than I can remember. When I continued to look into this stream of vocals that sounded the same, I came upon a quite obvious realization. Whether they know it or not, they are actually emulating Jim Morrison. It also makes sense that Eddie later played with the remaining Doors members and inducted them into the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame. This singing style wasn't just ho...

The Duck Walk

In honor of Angus Young's birthday today I've posted a little bit about his famous stage moves which he channeled from Chuck Berry. Angus, of course had his own more erratic spin on the dance move and made it his own. Check out the difference... "A one-legged hop routine, and the "duck walk", which he first used as a child when he walked "stooping with full-bended knees, but with my back and head vertical" under a table to retrieve a ball and his family found it entertaining; he used it when "performing in New York for the first time and some journalist branded it the duck walk." I love this guy's "Duck walk tutorial". "Just follow these easy steps...literally."

Fiberglass Jacket